Becoming a good singer is a journey that requires dedication, practice, and a deep understanding of the nuances of music. However, the path to mastery can vary significantly depending on the genre or style of singing you choose to pursue. In this blog, we’ll explore and compare the different approaches to learning singing in various traditions—Carnatic, Hindustani, Western, and Ghazals—and how each route shapes your musical journey.
Additionally, we will discuss how with advancement in technology, learning and mastering these genres of singing has become a lot more accessible and easier with Online singing lessons etc.
The different styles of singing in India and understanding their Discipline:
1. Carnatic Music: The Path of Precision and Discipline
Overview:
Carnatic music, one of the oldest classical music traditions in the world, originates from South India. It is known for its intricate melodies, complex rhythmic patterns, and devotional themes.
Learning Approach:
Guru-Shishya Parampara: Carnatic music is traditionally taught through the guru- shishya (teacher-student) model, where the student learns directly from a guru in a one-on-one setting. This method emphasizes oral transmission and close mentorship.
Foundation in Basics: Beginners start with Sarali Varisaigal (basic exercises) to master swaras (notes) and then progress to Janta Varisaigal, Alankaras, and Geetams. The focus is on building a strong foundation in pitch, rhythm, and voice modulation.
Rigorous Practice: Carnatic music demands daily practice, often starting with vocal warm-ups and exercises to improve flexibility and range.
Emphasis on Raga and Tala: Students learn to navigate through ragas (melodic frameworks) and talas (rhythmic cycles), which are the backbone of Carnatic music.
Performance-Oriented: The ultimate goal is to perform in concerts, often starting with small gatherings and progressing to larger audiences.
Challenges:
2. Hindustani Music: The Journey of Expression and Improvisation Overview:
Learning Approach:
Guru-Shishya Tradition: Like Carnatic music, Hindustani music is also taught through the guru-Shishya system, with a strong focus on oral transmission.
Alap and Taans: Beginners start with Alap (slow, melodic exploration) and gradually learn Taans (fast, intricate patterns) to develop vocal agility.
Raga Exploration: Hindustani music places a strong emphasis on understanding and improvising within ragas. Each raga is associated with a specific mood and time of day.
Khayal and Dhrupad Styles: Students often specialize in either Khayal (more popular, expressive) or Dhrupad (ancient, meditative) styles of singing.
Performance and Emotion: The focus is on conveying emotion (bhava) and connecting with the audience during performances.
Challenges:
3. Western Music: The Blend of Technique and Creativity
Overview:
Learning Approach:
Formal Training: Western singing is often taught in formal settings, such as music schools or conservatories, with a focus on reading sheet music and understanding music theory.
Vocal Techniques: Students learn techniques like breath control, vocal placement, and resonance to improve their singing. Genres like opera require a strong focus on classical techniques.
Repertoire Building: Singers work on a diverse repertoire, from classical arias to contemporary pop songs, depending on their interests.
Performance and Collaboration: Western music often involves ensemble singing, choirs, or bands, which teaches singers to blend their voices and work in harmony with others.
Use of Technology: Modern Western singers often use technology like microphones, audio editing software, and autotune to enhance their performances.
Challenges:
4. Ghazals: The Art of Storytelling Through Music
Overview:
Learning Approach:
Focus on Lyrics: Ghazal singing places a strong emphasis on understanding and conveying the meaning of the lyrics (sher). The singer must be able to evoke emotion through their voice.
Melodic Simplicity: Unlike classical traditions, ghazals often have simpler melodies, making them accessible to beginners. However, the challenge lies in expressing the depth of the poetry.
Influence of Classical Music: Many ghazal singers have a background in Hindustani classical music, which helps them navigate the ragas and taals used in ghazals.
Performance Style: Ghazal performances are intimate and often involve interaction with the audience. The singer must be able to connect emotionally with the listeners.
Challenges:
Mastering the art of storytelling through music requires a deep understanding of poetry and language.
The emotional depth of ghazals can be difficult to convey for beginners.
Comparing the Routes: Which One is Right for You?
Carnatic vs. Hindustani: Both are classical traditions, but Carnatic music is more structured and precise, while Hindustani music allows for more improvisation and emotional expression.
Western vs. Indian Classical: Western music emphasizes technical precision and versatility across genres, while Indian classical music focuses on deep exploration of ragas and talas.
Ghazals vs. Classical: Ghazals are more accessible and focus on lyrical expression, making them a good starting point for those who enjoy poetry and storytelling.
| Style | Structured Learning | Improvisation | Vocal Ornamentation | Emotional Expression | Technical Challenges |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Carnatic | Highly structured | Extensive | Heavy use of Ghamakhas | Moderate | Complex rhythmic structures |
| Hindustani | Structured but flexible | Significant | Use of meend, taans | High | Mastery of speed and emotional depth |
| Ghazals | Less structured | Minimal | Subtle vibrato, Legato phrasing | Very High | Mastery of poetry and Diction |
| Western Singing | Formal and technical | Limited | Minimal ornamentation | Moderate to high | Requires control over multiple registers and styles of singing |
Conclusion: Finding Your Musical Path
The journey to becoming a good singer is deeply personal, and the route you choose will depend on your interests, goals, and cultural background. Whether you’re drawn to the precision of Carnatic music, the improvisation of Hindustani music, the versatility of Western singing, or the poetic beauty of ghazals, each tradition offers a unique and rewarding path. The key is to stay committed, practice regularly, and most importantly, enjoy the process of making music. Online music lessons and online music classes can be valuable tools in this journey, providing accessibility and structured learning opportunities. Happy singing!!!
